Should You Buy a Pre-Owned Domain for SEO Purposes?

Should You Buy a Pre-Owned Domain for SEO Purposes?
  • 4 min read

So, you’re in the market for a pre-owned domain? We have just what you’re looking for! It only has 30,000 clicks and was owned by a little old lady in Peoria.

When it comes to pre-owned domains, don’t let yourself be taken for a ride. Investigate the current usage of any domain you’re eyeballing, identify the owner of the domain, and decide on the maximum amount you are willing to pay for it. Sounds easy enough, right? Well, let’s dive deeper so you don’t buy a domain clunker.

Navigating the World of Pre-Owned Domains: An SEO Perspective

Anyone who’s navigated the choppy waters of SEO (Search Engine Optimization) knows it’s not just about creating killer content and hoping for the best. It’s a complex dance of keywords, getting backlinks, and, surprisingly, domain history. Everyone has a history, right?

Welcome to the intriguing world of pre-owned domains and their potential SEO goldmines.

Picture this: You’re browsing through the digital marketplace, and you stumble upon a domain name that’s not only catchy, but also has a rich SEO history. It’s like finding a hidden treasure in a sea of internet chaos. But, like any savvy marketer, you wonder, “Is this too good to be true?”

What’s the Big Deal with Pre-Owned Domains?

In the world of SEO, a domain’s history is like its digital resume. A domain with a strong backlink profile, age, and keyword relevance can be a game-changer for your SEO efforts. It’s like starting a race halfway down the track. However, not all that glitters is gold.

And, for the record, Rocket bought the domain.

“After rebranding to, things really started to pick up with some big influencer wins in early 2022. In one month we more than 10x the size of the business and got beyond the first 100 customers. This is crucial because this was now 100+ people talking about”

Ben Gabler, CEO

It’s up to You to do Your Homework

Before you dive headfirst into purchasing a pre-owned domain, you need to play the domain detective. A bit of time invested, sure, but crucial nonetheless.

This process is a lot more involved thinking a domain has magic powers and adding a bunch of ChatGPT AI content is going to bring you success. It doesn’t work that way..

What skeletons could a domain have in its closet, you ask? 

Here are a few things to look out for:

  • Poor domain history: Was the domain previously used for spam or unethical practices, potentially harming reputation and SEO?
  • Legal risks: Previous illegal activities or trademark infringement on the domain could cause issues for you as the new owner.
  • Potential for poor backlink profile: A low Domain Authority could negatively affect SEO and website traffic.

Tools like Wayback Machine allow you to take a peek into the domain’s past life. Were the previous owners upstanding digital citizens, or was the domain part of the dark and spammy corners of the internet? Check the WHOIS History Lookup, too. It’s like CARFAX for Domain Names.

Looking for a Premium tool? Then you should check out Domain Tools.

If the domain you’re looking at is all clear, you’re good to go. If not, it might be time to say, “Ain’t nobody got time for this” and move on.

“Your domain likely has some history from previous owners. But can domain history impact your Google search rankings? … Google has … consistently stated that how a domain was used in the past can be a factor in how Google treats it today.”

Search Engine Journal

Navigating the Purchase: The Nitty-Gritty Details

Have you found a clean, penalty-free domain? Now onto the transaction. 

Platforms like GoDaddy Auctions or Sedo provide a marketplace for buying pre-owned domains. But, much like any purchase, it’s important to ensure everything is above board.

Double-check the domain’s history, ensure the seller is reputable, and, if possible, use an escrow service to protect your investment.

It’s Not Just About the SEO: Branding and Relevance Matter, Too

While the SEO benefits of a pre-owned domain are as tempting as a siren’s song, don’t forget the importance of branding and relevance. Does the domain align with your brand? Is it easy to remember? 

If not, you might find yourself with an SEO powerhouse that confuses your audience more than it helps your rankings. If you are looking to build a profitable niche website, does the domain name align well with other competitive sites?

And remember, like any good relationship, it takes time and effort. A pre-owned domain might give you a head start, but consistent, quality content and a solid SEO strategy are what will take you across the finish line.

“While your domain name itself isn’t considered to be a direct Google ranking factor, elements of your domain name may play into your overall SEO success. These include elements such as memorability, length, keyword usage, brand-ability, and more.”

Are You Ready to Take the Plunge?

If a pre-owned domain sounds like the right move for your SEO strategy, then dive in with your eyes wide open. Do your homework, ensure the domain is clean and penalty-free, and remember that while the SEO benefits are significant, branding and relevance are the cherries on top you don’t want to miss.

Let’s start the conversation.

Test Drive Your Pre-Owned Domain on the Fastest WordPress Host!

Good job spending top dollar on that quality domain name. Now you need to protect it with quality hosting that has your back with performance, security, and support by humans.

Let’s talk about how we can migrate your portfolio of client sites to, the fastest WordPress hosting in the world.

New call-to-action
More papers

More blog resources